TY - JOUR
T1 - Exploring how respect is articulated in Irish education policy, curriculum, circulars and legislation
AU - McCormack, Orla
AU - O’Flaherty, Joanne
AU - O’Grady, Emmanuel
N1 - Publisher Copyright:
© 2024 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group.
PY - 2024
Y1 - 2024
N2 - Respect as a term or value is often evoked to highlight a sense of esteem or right that an individual or group should require or be afforded. It is frequently viewed as relational, and central to the way people ought to relate to each other. However, the use of the term respect within classrooms, schools and policy can sometimes become so ubiquitous to the extent that it can become meaningless. Set against this context, this research analyses education documents relating to early childhood, primary and post-primary to consider the espoused positioning of respect within the Irish context. Sources were searched systematically using specific inclusion criteria, which resulted in 620 documents included in the sample, legislation (n = 40), policies (n = 50), active circulars (n = 179), archived circulars (n = 249) and curriculum specifications (n = 102). Following the application of thematic analysis, the authors suggest that ‘respect’ tends to be understood in six main ways: Respecting difference and diversity; mutual respect/ respect as relational; respecting the child; respecting the environment; respecting parents’ rights, views and values; and respecting the ‘ethos’ of the school. Some ways of understanding these conceptualisations and potential implications for schooling are discussed.
AB - Respect as a term or value is often evoked to highlight a sense of esteem or right that an individual or group should require or be afforded. It is frequently viewed as relational, and central to the way people ought to relate to each other. However, the use of the term respect within classrooms, schools and policy can sometimes become so ubiquitous to the extent that it can become meaningless. Set against this context, this research analyses education documents relating to early childhood, primary and post-primary to consider the espoused positioning of respect within the Irish context. Sources were searched systematically using specific inclusion criteria, which resulted in 620 documents included in the sample, legislation (n = 40), policies (n = 50), active circulars (n = 179), archived circulars (n = 249) and curriculum specifications (n = 102). Following the application of thematic analysis, the authors suggest that ‘respect’ tends to be understood in six main ways: Respecting difference and diversity; mutual respect/ respect as relational; respecting the child; respecting the environment; respecting parents’ rights, views and values; and respecting the ‘ethos’ of the school. Some ways of understanding these conceptualisations and potential implications for schooling are discussed.
KW - circulars
KW - curriculum
KW - implications for schools
KW - Irish legislation
KW - policies
KW - Respect
UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85189514244&partnerID=8YFLogxK
U2 - 10.1080/03323315.2024.2330884
DO - 10.1080/03323315.2024.2330884
M3 - Article
AN - SCOPUS:85189514244
SN - 0332-3315
JO - Irish Educational Studies
JF - Irish Educational Studies
ER -